JVS Report post Posted December 15, 2006 These guys got off like bandits...Seems like with 44 charges they should be in prison? Couple assessed $16,000 for poaching trophy elk and deer News Media Dec 14, 2006 Show Low couple assessed $16,000 for poaching trophy elk and deer New law on the books allows Game and Fish Commission to employ stiffer penalties PHOENIX – A Show Low couple convicted of multiple violations relating to the poaching of a trophy-class elk and a mule deer became the first violators to feel the effects of a new law on the books allowing the Arizona Game and Fish Commission to employ tougher penalties, especially for repeat or gross offenders. John D. Polzin was civilly assessed a total of $16,000: $8,000 for the loss of a 6x6 bull elk and $8,000 for the loss of a 7x5 mule deer buck to the state. In order to quantify the loss of the trophy animals to the State of Arizona, the Game and Fish Department enlisted the help of an official appraiser. In addition, the Game and Fish Commission revoked the hunting, fishing and trapping privileges of John Polzin for 10 years and Shelly L. Polzin for five years (the maximum possible for each case). The Polzins must also successfully complete an Arizona hunter education course prior to having their license privileges restored in this state. But the commission’s action to revoke their licenses has more far-reaching implications for the Polzins. Arizona is a member of the Interstate Wildlife Violator Compact with 22 other states. For the Polzins, that means they will not be able to legally hunt in any of those states until their license privileges are restored in Arizona. The action by the Game and Fish Commission in the Polzin case would not have been possible had it not been for the newly-bolstered wildlife law, sponsored by Rep. Jerry Weiers, R-Glendale, which was passed by the Arizona Legislature and signed by Gov. Janet Napolitano in May of 2006. This new law, which took effect in September, creates a system of civil assessments and license revocations based on the number of convictions an individual has for unlawfully taking or wounding wildlife. The new law also allows the Game and Fish Commission to permanently revoke or suspend a person’s hunting privileges for various offenses, including unlawfully taking trophy or endangered species. “In the past, the Game and Fish Commission could only revoke a violator’s hunting, fishing and trapping licenses for a maximum of five years, no matter how severe or egregious the case…not any more. Now when we have serious offenses, we can employ stiffer penalties,” says Commissioner Mike Golightly of Flagstaff. Wildlife Manager Robert Birkland, the investigating officer in the case, says the Game and Fish Commission sent a strong message that Arizona’s wildlife is a valuable asset owned by the people of Arizona. “Hopefully the new law will serve as a deterrent to potential violators,” he says. The commission’s actions were made possible because the couple had already been found guilty by the courts. John D. and Shelly L. Polzin of Show Low were indicted by a Navajo County grand jury for a total of 44 charges, but entered a plea agreement last spring where the charges were reduced. John Polzin pleaded guilty to five charges, including taking a mule deer buck without valid license or tag, possessing an unlawfully taken mule deer buck, obtaining a 2005 resident hunting and fishing license by fraud, taking a bull elk without valid license and tag, and possessing an unlawfully taken bull elk. Shelly Polzin pleaded guilty to three charges, including possessing an unlawfully taken mule deer buck, obtaining a 2006 resident hunting and fishing license by fraud, and possessing an unlawfully taken bull elk. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
DesertBull Report post Posted December 15, 2006 It was because of the plea bargain. The two morons decided to plead guilty, saving the state a lot of money in trial expenses. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
More D Report post Posted December 15, 2006 I have know idea but I bet the guide service and trophy fees would be in that range for game of that caliber. I'd bet my lunch money that they won't even pay the fine. A fine and not being able to hunt legaly is nothing them. They were poaching a.k.a taking game during the wrong dates, without tag, etc....etc so why take away the right to to do some thing they never cared about to begin with. How about taking away there ol' huntin truck and rifle with a few days in the slammer to boot. I bet that would change things. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
phx hunter Report post Posted December 16, 2006 You said it right, D. I often hear about these repeat offenders of poaching. They clearly don't think hunting laws matter. I know the officials have to punish them some how but I always find it funny when they take away the hunting license of someone who was hunting without a license. I guess that showed them. Clearly they will stop now that it is against the law for them to hunt. Oh well maybe two less applicants in the pool. Although the bonus point they will get for the class they have to take might just give them the incentive to play by the rules. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
tucrats Report post Posted December 16, 2006 I received this article in my e-mail as well. I think is great that they are getting tougher on these guy's! Maybe if it is brought out in the main stream media, People will finally get it! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
