Simple Question- 1.5" or 2"

[John O]

So assuming they both group well, and plenty of KE for a pass through, would you prefer a 1.5" three blade or a 2" two blade mechanical for whitetail. I have shot both deer and pigs with two and three blade designs, with mixed results (and yes I realize shot placement plays a HUGE part in this). I think I have made up my mind, but would like to get some additional feedback.

[rancilio]

Three blade non-mechanical.

[AxisWorks LLC]

2' 2 blade for me.

[DCS]

3 blade leaves a better blood trail for me.

[123456]

Don't care how big the cut, just use a fixed blade. I like 1 1/6 cut on a fixed. Seems to be a lethal dose everytime.

[Elkhunter1Jr]

swhacker 100gr

[John O]

3 blade Slayer and 2" Swhacker are my two options. Leaning towards the Slayers.

[Elkhunter1Jr]

3 blade Slayer and 2" Swhacker are my two options. Leaning towards the Slayers.

3 blade Slayer and 2" Swhacker are my two options. Leaning towards the Slayers.

i like swhacker because they don't open in the air

[Will K]

Shot placement is the key with any broadhead. Good luck.

[gauchoand]

3 blade ..... think hole compared to a nice 2" knife cut

[AxisWorks LLC]

2" rage on this years whitetail. First pic is entrance, 2nd pic. is exit.

[KiLLAcOuEs]

Swhacker 100gr. 2"

[AZHUNTER05]

This is the entry hole on my elk this year with a 2 blade rage.