I have had my Pronghorns since 2008 and they are the best boots I have ever owned. They are light, comfortable and I have never gotten wet feet in snow, rain or even walking in ankle deep water. Mine do not have the heel or toe protector but it hasn't seemed to affect their performance. After every hunting trip I just put shoe polish on them, buff them out and then spray with Camp Dry or something similar and they are like new again. I love them and I think you would be happy with them if you decided to buy them.